Recently, some courts have challenged Amazon’s claim that it is not a seller. In 2020, an appeals court in San Diego found that Amazon was liable for a laptop battery that exploded and gave a woman severe burns. In 2021, another California court determined that Amazon was liable for a toy hoverboard that caught fire and burned a woman. Last July, the Consumer Product Safety Commission sued Amazon to force the recall of hazardous products being sold by third parties on its site. The ones they found included 24,000 faulty carbon monoxide detectors, 400,000 hair dryers that lacked immersion protection devices to prevent shock and electrocution, and “numerous” children’s pajamas that did not meet flammable fabric safety standards. Amazon moved to dismiss the case, claiming it served only as a “third-party logistics provider” — like a shopping mall — but in January, an administrative law judge ruled that it was a “distributor,” like a store, under the Consumer Product Safety Act. (An Amazon representative told The Times, “While we continue to disagree with the notion that we are a distributor, we share CPSC’s commitment to customer and product safety and will continue working toward that goal.”)

Outside the courts, federal agencies have called for online retailers — including Amazon — to police their marketplaces for fraud, particularly counterfeit and defective goods. And since 2020, legislators from both parties have introduced bills that would compel e-commerce platforms to do more to verify the identities of sellers. Versions of one such bill, the INFORM Consumers Act, have been introduced in 18 state legislatures, with support from lobbyists that represent Walmart and other major retail chains. So far, only Arkansas, Walmart’s home state, has passed one. But this year, a version of the act was included as a section of another bill that passed both houses of Congress and is now in the reconciliation process. Amazon supported the bill after lawmakers incorporated the company’s “concerns” into the text. An Amazon representative told The Times that the company supports “a federal approach that will avoid imposing inconsistent obligations on sellers.”

Even if Walmart has self-interested reasons for backing the INFORM Consumers Act, it seems difficult to argue with the claim that e-commerce platforms should vet businesses that sell large volumes of products through them or be liable for accidents, just as brick-and-mortar stores typically are. One important element is missing from the act, though: In addition to offering more clarity to customers, Amazon should become more accountable to the sellers who are its customers, too, by offering them clearer ways to dispute automated decisions and fairer terms for arbitration.

The automated processes that Amazon uses to govern its Marketplace at scale will make mistakes; all algorithms do. They will also be gameable; all algorithms are. To small business owners who depend on Amazon for their livelihood and take on debt to scale, mistaken punishment and unfair gaming can be devastating. If new rules are put in place without clear avenues for appeal, they will motivate sellers to seek workarounds that undermine the marketplace integrity that the bill strives to create.

Amazon does not want to hurt customers. On the contrary, almost everything about Amazon is optimized to please its customers. Like some other retailers, the company often does not even require refunded merchandise to be returned. Amazon did not invent outsourcing, or single-handedly create the inequalities that it profits from, any more than Facebook and YouTube invented lying or Uber created the precarities that motivate many of its drivers to sign up. But as Amazon makes aspects of global exploitation more efficient, its growing monopolistic power means that more and more of commerce operates on its terms. As the broad public has come to recognize of social media, those terms include a great deal of opacity and impunity for platforms themselves.

Narratives of injury engross us because they point to tangible harms — blindings and burns and broken bones. They play to concrete fears and offer individual resolutions. Amazon has every interest in presenting problems in its marketplace as the fault of a few bad actors. So do politicians. It is hard to get constituents excited about cracking down on a company that most of them like and use regularly. It is easier to blame the failures of that company on distant Chinese manufacturers — to point to racialized others who are already objects of animus, rather than to a system that implicates most American adults. But the prospect of injury without relief — a prospect that workers in fulfillment centers face much more frequently than customers — should not make us turn to Amazon for solutions; rather, it should raise the question of whether such cheap, fast consumption is, in fact, desirable.

Bad actors exist. But they are acting within a system that is set up to create them.

Moira Weigel is an assistant professor of communication studies at Northeastern University.

The Times is committed to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. We’d like to hear what you think about this or any of our articles. Here are some tips. And here’s our email: [email protected].

Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Twitter (@NYTopinion) and Instagram.

By admin

One thought on “What You Don’t Know About Amazon”
  1. brawl stars gems generator brawl stars hack free cash app money free cash app money generator free clash of clans hack free clash of clans hack free clash of clans hack free coin master spins free spins coin master free discord nitro generator free discord nitro generator dragon city free gems generator dragon city hack free amazon gift card generator amazon gift card generator Free Among us mod bloons td 6 free free bloons td 6 apk free cash app money free cash app money generator free cash app money free cash app money generator free cash app money free cash app money generator free cash app money free cash app money generator free cash app money free cash app money generator free coin master spins free spins coin master free discord nitro generator free fire hack generator free fire hack free fire hack generator free fire hack free fire hack generator free fire hack free fire hack generator free fire hack free fire hack generator free fire hack free fortnite skins generator free fortnite skins free google play gift card generator google play codes free homescapes hack homescapes hack free instagram followers generator free instagram followers kim kardashian hollywood hack onlyfans hack free onlyfans hack free psn codes generator free psn codes generator free psn codes generator free robux free robux generator free robux free robux generator free robux free robux generator free robux free robux generator free tiktok followers generator free tiktok followers generator Free v bucks Free v bucks Free v bucks generator Free v bucks Free v bucks generator Free v bucks Free v bucks Free v bucks generator Free v bucks Free v bucks generator Free v bucks Free v bucks Free v bucks generator Free v bucks Free v bucks generator Free v bucks Free v bucks Free v bucks generator Free v bucks Free v bucks generator walmart gift card generator free xbox gift card generator free instagram followers generator free instagram followers free fire hack generator free fire hack free fire hack generator free fire hack gta 5 money hack gta 5 money hack free fortnite skins generator free fortnite skins free homescapes hack homescapes hack free pokemon go spoofer free fire hack generator free fire hack free imvu credits generator free instagram followers generator free instagram followers free instagram followers generator free instagram followers free itunes gift card generator kim kardashian hollywood hack nintendo eshop gift card generator pixel gun 3d hack pixel gun 3d online hack free pokemon go spoofer free pubg mobile uc generator simcity hack generator steam gift card generator Free v bucks Free v bucks Free v bucks generator Free v bucks Free v bucks generator Free v bucks Free v bucks Free v bucks generator Free v bucks Free v bucks generator free xbox gift card generator brawl stars gems generator brawl stars hack

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *